|
Media Center 2005
I have been thinking about putting a PC in the living room for some time. A friend of mine, Andrew Brust, did it and raves about it. He used a standard Windows XP machine and loves CinemaNow as well as using it to play MP3s.
I have been on the fence. I bought a Phillips Tivo the week they came out. Hacked it of course and way happy with the 80GB capacity. I then upgraded to a Hughes DirectTivo which I for the most part love. The only part I don't like is my fault. I immediately upgraded it to two 200GB drives. What this translates to is that when I am navigating Now Playing there is a significant pause of sometimes two or three minutes while it reads the catalog off disk. My understanding is that this is due to the limited memory of the device combined with how large I have made the file system. There is at least one company offering a hack to add more memory to remove this problem. However I digress...
I have wanted a way to play our MP3 collection in the family room for some time now. We ripped all our CDs and then put them in the attic. I got rid of two 400 disc changers and pretty much just use my wife's iPod as our music source. Problem is that it is a pain to pull it out of the cabinet to change playlists, etc and when she is gone I am SOL. I have looked at a ton of options for this including the Roku and others from a variety of providers. The Tivo Home Media Option would work great however I have a Series 1 Tivo that doesn't support it and a DirectTivo that doesn't yet offer it because DirectTV hasn't decided to bless their subscribers with the feature.
Hence I yearningly look at the Media Center. It appears it would solve the MP3 problem handily. However last time I looked at one I couldn't justify spending almost $2000 for a media player that looks like I took a computer from my office and placed it next to my TV. It looks like prices are coming down however and at least HP has gotten a clue and is now offering a Media Center that looks more like a stereo component at a reasonable price. The kicker however is ultimately I would like to replace my DirectTivo with it. The only way however to do this appears to be to go back to my old cable receiver, use an IR blaster to control it, and then take the signal off the S-Video output of the receiver. This is going back several generations to how my old Tivo Series 1 used to do it. In fact it is going back even further since at least the Tivo could control the receiver via the serial port. The Media Center from what I can tell doesn't even offer that. Furthermore I lose the fidelity of storing the MPEG stream from DirectTV directly. Instead it gets decompressed, converted to S-Video, and then re-encoded by the Media Center.
I guess what I am still holding out for is someone to make a DirectTV tuner card for the Media Center PC. I am not holding my breathe however given how idiotic DirectTV can be at times...
Wednesday, October 13, 2004 8:29:12 AM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
|