Tuesday, January 23, 2007

IBM Thinkpad has finally jumped the Shark

I have been an IBM Thinkpad user for I think around 10 years now.  I think the first one was a 760Z and I have been through around 4–5 of them now.

I like everyone else rely heavily upon my laptop.  When traveling around the world to present at conferences I can’t show up at a location with a dead laptop.  To that end I have had great experience with Thinkpads and clearly other speakers have also.  Go into any speaker lounge and in my experience 65–70% of the speakers will be carrying thinkpads for the exact same reason.  Makes it nice also if you forget a power supply, etc!

Tonight I had an issue with my 10 month old T60p.  I upgraded it to Vista Ultimate RTM in November shortly after it became available.  I have avoided putting any beta software on this machine.  See above about not showing up with a dead machine…

I plugged it into a projector the other day at a client site and it came up black and white!  That’s weird.  Thought it might be the projector.  Tried a different one.  Still black and white.

Thought it might be the hardware so I swapped hard drives to an XP image I have and tried it.  Color shows up just fine.

Got the latest ATI driver from the IBM support site.  Still had the problem.  Waited a couple weeks and got a newer driver off the IBM site released on 1/22/07.  Same problem.

Called IBM support and was told: “IBM will not support Vista unless it came from the factory pre-installed on the system.  Full packaged product purchased and later installed is not supported.” Renee Martin – IBM Support Atlanta

Whoa!  A laptop that I bought 10 months ago with a 3 year warranty is now no longer supported because Microsoft released an operating system upgrade.  One in fact that IBM/Lenovo will be shipping pre-installed on almost identical hardware very soon.

I was a bit worried about the Lenovo acquisition like many but figured they had one or two more designs left in them that were collaborations with IBM.  The 3000 series confirmed that machines designed solely by Lenovo were not going to suit my needs.

I think this is the turning point where they finally jumped the shark.  Time to start looking at other notebook vendors.  I am not thrilled by Dell quality/support.  HP notebooks are uninspiring to say the least.  It might be, I shudder to say it, MacBook Pro w/bootcamp time.

Tuesday, January 23, 2007 6:55:31 PM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)   #      Comments [3]  
 

Tuesday, January 23, 2007 7:58:16 PM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
The dell guys haven't been doing a very good job either. I heard from a support guy today that they're not really planning on providing drivers for anything but the last generation of machines (meaning no dell drivers for my inspiron 6000 I bought last year), and don't even get me started about printer drivers from dell (almost non-existant at this point).
Tuesday, January 23, 2007 8:07:02 PM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
Hi Chris, I've been using a MacBook Pro with Bootcamp and Parallels for the last 9 months. I was in the Thinkpad-Forever camp before that. The MacBook Pro is a very nice laptop, and I have become even more fond of it over time. But it's not a great Windows laptop.

Negatives:
1. Right now Bootcamp doesn't even support Vista at all.
2. No built-in Verizon (have to get a new ExpressCard for $199 on ebay)
3. No right-mouse-click. Two fingered click makes up for that, if bootcamp supports it.
4. Fewer keys: No home/end or PgUp/PgDn, or even Delete keys. You'll really miss them.
5. DVI port. There's a small VGA adapter, but you'll end up forgetting it for at least one presentation!

If you're mostly going to run Windows on it, I wouldn't recommend a MacBook Pro. For Windows laptops, I think Thinkpads are still the best ones out there. The new X60 Tablet will have 1400x900 resolution (on a 12" screen) and Verizon built-in.

While we're add it... I got a Mac because I want to get more familiar/comfortable with Unix and Linux. After 9 months I can say that it has worked, and I actually get very annoyed in a DOS command line, whishing I had Unix commands available. Getting a Mac has been a great way for me to explore to the non-Windows world.
Tuesday, January 23, 2007 8:08:54 PM (Pacific Standard Time, UTC-08:00)
Oh, and one more negative: No good docking station! There's a third-party solution, but it's very clumsy.
Comments are closed.

Administration
Sign In